I am in reciept of an e-mail being passed around with great Emerald Ash Borer resource information for decision making purposes in ash tree management and treatment options. The relevant text is as follows:
As the EAB situation heats up and people become pressed into action, it is important to focus on the scientific basis for particular recommendations. As you know, there is a consensus bulletin from Extension Specialists in Ohio (Herms), Michigan (McCullough and Smitley), Indiana (Sadof), Illinois (Nixon), and Wisconsin (Willliamson) that presents a measured discussion about the advantages and disadvantages of various pesticide options. It is available at the regional EAB website and I have it posted on the Indiana webpage in an interactive format or as a pdf at this link <http://extension.entm.purdue.edu/EAB/index.php?page=faq>. It was put together to serve as an unbiased source of information for the region.
At Purdue, we have developed a free web based cost calculator <http://extension.entm.purdue.edu/treecomputer/index.php> that helps you use estimates to project costs over a 25 year period under sets of assumptions that you can tailor to your local conditions. This includes the size of your ash forest, and size based estimates for treatment, removal and replacement costs, rates of ash mortality and replacement tree mortality.
In addition to projecting costs, the calculator also projects the size of the remaining ash forest over time. While this is not a formal cost benefit analysis, it allows you to compare what you will be getting from implementing various scenarios. The calculator allows you to compare several default management scenarios (treat all, replace all, remove all ash with out replacment; remove large trees, replace large trees, replace big trees) with detailed explanations of the rationale and what each management program entails. If none of the management scenarios suits you, it even allows you to create your own management scenario.
Best Wishes,
Cliff Sadof
Professor and Extension Entomologist
Purdue University